JESHS

Peer Review Process

Review model: JESHS uses double-blind peer review. Every research article that passes editorial screening is sent to at least two independent reviewers; an additional reviewer may be invited where reports materially conflict.

1. Editorial screening

Submissions are screened for scope fit, scholarly contribution, methodological soundness, technical compliance, ethics declarations and anonymisation.

2. Reviewer selection

Reviewers are selected for subject expertise, scholarly competence and independence. Individuals with a significant conflict involving the authors, funder or study are not appointed.

3. Assessment and decision

Reviewers assess originality, methodology, data and analysis, support for conclusions, references, ethical compliance and presentation. Decisions may be accept, minor revision, major revision or reject. Reviewers advise; the final decision remains editorial.

4. Confidentiality

Manuscripts are confidential. Reviewers and editors must not use unpublished material for personal benefit or disclose it to unauthorised third parties.

5. Indicative review timelines

JESHS aims to provide timely but rigorous evaluation. Typical timeframes are 2–5 business days for initial technical checks, 5–10 days for editorial screening, 3–7 days for reviewer invitation and confirmation, 14–21 days for external peer review, and 7–21 days for author revision depending on the extent of changes requested. A final editorial decision on a revised manuscript is usually made within 3–7 days. These are indicative, not guaranteed, and may vary with reviewer availability, revision complexity or the need for additional expert assessment; the journal does not guarantee acceptance or publication by a specific date.